What was your favourite book of 2009 and least favourite? That was the question I put to my guests (Maggie Perkovic, Ro Bennett & Babs Simpson) and the listeners. Also visitors & possibly a local or two, logged their favourites throughout the year. So here's what my guests had to say:
Ro's favourite: Janet Evanovitch - Finger Lickin 15. Ro loves the humour of her books and looks forward to the next year when the follow on comes along.
Ro's least favourite: Susan Hill - The Beacon. The story was boring, the characters easily forgetable and the plot? It left Ro wondering what was that about?
Masggie's favourite: The Great Lover by Jill Dawson: Maggie loves this era early 1900's, and really enjoyed reading about Rupert Brooke, who was held up as a glamorous romantic poet,(see her review on this blog).
Maggie's least favourite: Jacky Trevane - Invisible women: Maggie enjoyed the first book 'Fatwa' but didn't enjoy this one as she felt it was just cashing in on other peoples tales.
Bab's favourite: Markus Zusak - The Book Thief: Death is a brilliant character in this very unusual book. It is beautifully written and set in the WW2 era which Babs loves. But on a par was 'Guernsey Potato Peel Pie and Literary Society' written by Annie Barrows & Mary Ann Shaffer. Again set in 1940's during WW2 it told of the German Occupation of Guernsey through letters.
Bab's least favourite: Victoria Hislop - The Return: Babs loved the Island (based on a Cretan leper colony) but this book set during the Spanish civil war was a disappointment. I felt that I was reading an article from an encyclopaedia and the story around it was dull and predictable. I had to agree with Babs on this one!
Some listeners comments:
Steve Watt: Best Book - undoubtedly 'Wolf Hall' by Hilary Mantel A brilliant historical novel but I have to put a word in for Cormac McArthy's 'Border Trilogy' (see reviews in this blog). As for the worst I only managed the first three pages of 'The Lost Symbol' by Dan Brown - admirably and accurately described by the Guardian as 'a steaming pile of clunk.'
Ellie: best & worst both by same author Stephanie Meyer. Best, 'Eclipse', because it had a lot of action and bit of gore. Worst, 'New Moon',because nothing much happened in it.
Win Grant: Best book Hilary Mantel - Wolf Hall
Toby (St Martins Bakery): Jose Saramago - Blindness
Here's what the visitors said:
BOOK, AUTHOR & COMMENTS
Paul Torday - Salmon fishing in the Yemen: excellent read, unusual, reminds me of tv series 'yes misister'
Dodie Smith - I capture the Castle: My favourite book ever! Especially the bit with the escaped bear on the train
Jo Verity - Sweets From Morocco:I wrote it!
Edwar Cummings - Ghosts of Rosevear: Very interesting - and a good read too based on an island off St Agnes
Mark Haddon - The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nightime: About autisitic boy sometimes amusing & shocking, a real insight
Thomas Bloor - Worm in the Blood: Wonderful love story that shouldn't work but really does make me cry
Tom Rob-Smith - child 44: Gripping crime novel set in Stalinist Russia. Realistic and ultimately haunting
Ian Sansom - The Case of the Missing Books: Quicrky & humourus novel about a Jewish librarian who takes up a job in Ireland only to find all the books missing
John Connelly - Bad Men: Spooky crime thriller set on an island off the coast of Maine USA
Sue Monk Kidd - The Secret Life of Bees A wonderful story out of nowhere which sends you on a roller coaster of emotions but end up feel good. Set at the start of the 1960's civil rights movement.
Gabriel Garcia Marquez - 100 years of Solitude a complex & involving story of one family in South America. It slowly tells a potted history of the continent as seen through eccentric eyes.
Terry Pratchett - Unseen Academicals: Brilliant!
Stephanie Meyer - Twilight Saga: NEVER a fan of romance, but enjoyed Twilight! Currently curbing my obsession!
My favourite? Chris Cleave 'The Other Hand', it really made me stop and think differently about some of the plights of immigrants held in detention centres.
Worst: Spies of Warsaw by Alan Furst: boring & dull and I didn't care what happened to the characters (who were they anyway?).
Happy New Year to all! (definition of a hangover: Wrath of Grapes!)
Showing posts sorted by date for query Jacky Trevane. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query Jacky Trevane. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Friday, 1 January 2010
Saturday, 8 August 2009
Jacky Trevane - Fatwa Living with a Death Threat & Invisible Women
Review by Maggie Perkovic 6th August 09
Jacky was 23yrs old when she arrived in Egypt for a holiday with her boyfriend of three years, Dave.
Little did she know that an innocent holiday would result in a horror beyond her imagination. Separated from Dave in a bustling street, Jacky fell and twisted her ankle only to be swept up by a handsome and chivalrous Egyptian called Omar. It was love at first sight for the both of them.
jacky spent her holiday with Omar's family, sharing a bed with Omar's sister and learning all about Egypt from his family. Swept away from her infatuation she marries Omar then returns to England to tell her parents and return to Cairo to make her future with her husband.
Dave meets her on the flight home, says he had a great time with some drinking buddies but is unimpressed with her new status as a married woman. Returning to Cairo against her parents advice but full of hopes and plans Jacky's dream turns into a nightmare. As a blue eyed blonde she was never going to fit in with life in a poor suburb where the women walked at all times with their heads bowed. during the next six years her seemingly gallant husband subjected her to non stop physical and emotional abuse, when he starts on their little girls she knows she has to escape, but how??
This story is quite riveting, as you listen to the way she effects their escape, knowing that if he finds out they will be punished severely. Her life is quite unbearable though she tries to make the best of it. an attack by her brothers in law where her husband blames her instead of them makes her realise just how untenable her situation is.
I think we must judge her as foolish without knowing the culture of the country she marries him, even after living it for 10 days!!!
Invisible Women is rather contrived with several references to The Fatwas, she runs a helpline for women in similar circumstances, ie who are abused and ignored etc. Laura is mentally abused and ostracised by her family, Charlotte has an eating disorder, Shygirl was in same situation as Jacky but continues to live with him.
I found the first book quite absorbing but the second not quite so convincing.
The author still has the Fatwas (death threat) on her life.
Jacky was 23yrs old when she arrived in Egypt for a holiday with her boyfriend of three years, Dave.
Little did she know that an innocent holiday would result in a horror beyond her imagination. Separated from Dave in a bustling street, Jacky fell and twisted her ankle only to be swept up by a handsome and chivalrous Egyptian called Omar. It was love at first sight for the both of them.
jacky spent her holiday with Omar's family, sharing a bed with Omar's sister and learning all about Egypt from his family. Swept away from her infatuation she marries Omar then returns to England to tell her parents and return to Cairo to make her future with her husband.
Dave meets her on the flight home, says he had a great time with some drinking buddies but is unimpressed with her new status as a married woman. Returning to Cairo against her parents advice but full of hopes and plans Jacky's dream turns into a nightmare. As a blue eyed blonde she was never going to fit in with life in a poor suburb where the women walked at all times with their heads bowed. during the next six years her seemingly gallant husband subjected her to non stop physical and emotional abuse, when he starts on their little girls she knows she has to escape, but how??
This story is quite riveting, as you listen to the way she effects their escape, knowing that if he finds out they will be punished severely. Her life is quite unbearable though she tries to make the best of it. an attack by her brothers in law where her husband blames her instead of them makes her realise just how untenable her situation is.
I think we must judge her as foolish without knowing the culture of the country she marries him, even after living it for 10 days!!!
Invisible Women is rather contrived with several references to The Fatwas, she runs a helpline for women in similar circumstances, ie who are abused and ignored etc. Laura is mentally abused and ostracised by her family, Charlotte has an eating disorder, Shygirl was in same situation as Jacky but continues to live with him.
I found the first book quite absorbing but the second not quite so convincing.
The author still has the Fatwas (death threat) on her life.
6th August 09
Guests this week were Maggie Perkovich and Lydia Birch. Lydia did a review of all of the Twilight series - she was dissappointed in the last one, felt it was 'a book too far' but had thoroughly enjoyed the rest. I threw down the gauntlet to her to read other vampire books out there such as Rachel Caine, Charlaine Harris, Lesley Sands, to compare to the Twilight stuff.
Maggie got serious this week and reviewed two books by the same author, Jacky Trevane. These books are about women marrying into other cultures and being subjected to physical & emotional abuse.
I read the blurb and thought what a boyfriend she had, to just go off drinking & leave her in Cairo, plus, what was she on? To meet and marry someone within weeks from a completely different culture and live in their country, as she did...........?
Maggie got serious this week and reviewed two books by the same author, Jacky Trevane. These books are about women marrying into other cultures and being subjected to physical & emotional abuse.
I read the blurb and thought what a boyfriend she had, to just go off drinking & leave her in Cairo, plus, what was she on? To meet and marry someone within weeks from a completely different culture and live in their country, as she did...........?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
